Partition of India Partition of India Partition of Punjab Partition of India Formation of Pakistan Partition of India Partition of India Gallery
Punjab Partition Partition of India and Pakistan

 

PunjabPartition.com

Sikh News
 

 

Sikh Sangat Network

Copyright ©2001 -  2008


In India, there is no institutional memory of Partition: the State has not seen fit to construct any memorials, to mark any particular places - as has been done, say, in the case of Holocaust memorials, or memorials for the Vietnam War.

There is nothing at the border that marks it as a place where millions of people crossed, no plaque or memorial at any of the sites of the camps, nothing that marks a particular spot as a place where Partition memories are collected.

Partition was the dark side of independence: the question then is, how can it be memorialized by the State without the State recognizing its own complicity?

It is true that hundreds of thousands of people died as a result of Partition. A half century later, you might well be able to read them as martyrs to the cause of forging a new nation. But alongside, there is also the other, inescapable reality that millions of people were killed and in many families where there were deaths, there were probably also murders.

How do you memorialize such a history? What do you commemorate? For people, for the State, what is at stake in remembering? To what do you have to be true in order to remember?

It was not only that people killed those of the "other" religion, but in hundreds of instances, they killed people of their own families; it was not only that men of one religion raped women of the other, but in hundreds of instances, men raped women of the same religion.

What can you do to mark such a history as anything other than a history of shame? No matter how much Indian politicians, members of the Congress, tried to see themselves as reluctant players in the game, they could not escape the knowledge that they accepted Partition as the cost of freedom. Such histories are not easily memorialized.

In many countries in the world today, there are memorials to moments of conflict and upheaval. Either with State support or otherwise, scholars have painstakingly built up meticulous archives of people's testimonies, of photographs, letters, documents, memoirs, books in which such historical moments are represented.

Very little of this exists for Partition. Until recently, little attempt has been made even to collect people's accounts. Visual representations of Partition - despite the rich archive of photographs that must exist in many newspapers and magazines - remain limited, and while a half century of Indian independence has called for all manner of celebratory events, little has been done to mark this important event in the history of India.

But while there is no public memory of Partition, inside homes and families, the memory is kept alive through remembrance rituals and stories that mark particular events.

When Mangal Singh and his two brothers came away from their village, carrying with them the burden of the death of seventeen of their family members, they built a commemorative plaque with all seventeen names on it, and had it placed in the Golden Temple in Amritsar. An annual forty-eight-hour reading of the Sikh scriptures was held to mark the occasion of their deaths, to commemorate their martyrdom.

For the rest of their lives, Mangal Singh's brothers attended the religious ceremony with him each year. After their deaths, he went to it, usually alone, but sometimes accompanied by Trilok Singh, the sole survivor of the family deaths.

When I asked Mangal Singh, many years later, how he had lived with these memories, he pointed around him to the fertile fields of Punjab. He said: "All of us who came from there, Partition refugees, we have put all our forgetting into working this land, into making it prosper".

Author: Urvashi Butalia

   

Sikh Sangat Network

SikhPride · Sikh Discussion  Forums · Sikh Global News · Sikh Videos · Youth Interviews
Dabar Sahib · GurkiBani (Audio) · Sikh Chronicle · Sikh Charity · Bhai Sahib
· Saragarhi.org · Punjab Partition